I now believe more than ever that that Carrie Ann profile on Facebook is REAL because there are now posts back & forth between her & Brent Barcus!!!! He was in Shania's Band & knows Carrie personally!
So if the two of them are posting to eachother, she's gotta be real!!!!!!!!!
Hey Ren...I know someone from the STC who has a MUCH stronger opinion of this than you..I was told in no uncertain terms..IT IS A FAKE
You are wrong Bob, it is her. Some band memeber have talked to her and it is her. I can't believe we are still aguing about if it is her or not. Bobby, you know how I like you and think most of your posts are great. But you have been wrong quite a bit lately on your socalled sources and socalled people you talk to. If you actually had any source then name it instead of claiming to talk to someone at the STC. Because I have emailed someone close to the STC and they say it is Carrie Ann and they have exchanged posts. I think it is clear it is Carrie Ann because nobody with credibiliy has come here and said it isn't/ Angie saw the post about Carrie Ann and never said anything and never shot it down. Nobody from the STC has come here to stop the rumors and shoot it down.Nobody from Shania's band has come here to shoot it down. Sorry folks, it is Carrie Ann, stop being so paranoid.
-- Edited by EveryBodyLovesKevy at 11:12, 2009-01-09
I'm almost convinced it`s someone doing a real good job of faking it.
Notice there are no pictures of CA other than those that have been posted in magazines or on the internet.
Just my opinion... I dont know for sure.
Wrong, it is her, some band memebers know her and said that is her profile and that is her. Also she said she uses pictures that people are already familar with. She doesn't want to share private pictures of herself.
Folks listen to your Guru...Posted above is the statement, that the reason she does not put her own pictures on facebook but instead scans from mags is because she is a private person..Secondly if what the band members are telling walter is it true..BRING THEM ON...AND LASTLY.. The insanity that Carrie is so private that she won't post ACTUAL pictures of her,BUT not so private that she well tell unknowns all about her sister..INSANITY...Anyhoe..Until Sunday....Solong
Folks listen to your Guru...Posted above is the statement, that the reason she does not put her own pictures on facebook but instead scans from mags is because she is a private person..Secondly if what the band members are telling walter is it true..BRING THEM ON...AND LASTLY.. The insanity that Carrie is so private that she won't post ACTUAL pictures of her,BUT not so private that she well tell unknowns all about her sister..INSANITY...Anyhoe..Until Sunday....Solong
-- Edited by Bobby Boy at 11:10, 2009-01-09
Here is a fact that you seem to ignore. Why has nobody at all with crediblity shot this rumor down. The rumor about Carrie Ann has been going on for awhile. Why hasn't Angie who logged in on Jan 3rd shot the rumor down? Why hasn't any band member who browse this site shot the rumor down? Why hasn't an authority from the STC come to this site and shot the rumor down? Nobody with credibility has shot this rumor down at all. The facts are that Carrie Ann does have a facebook account and that is her profile, stop being so paranoid. You claim to talk to someone from the STC, Well as you say bring it on. Tell that person to come here and shoot the rumor down. I am guessing you think all the band members exchanging posts with her and emailing her are fake too lol!!!
OMG..Trying to base a case on circumstantial evidence that is based on WHYS..
TRUST ME FOLKS...WHYS mean NOTHING. Do me a favour....Go pick up some mags today..Ya know the really crappy ones..Read them and then ASK...WHY do none of these stars or PR people who represent them come forward any deny them?? Just a couple of weeks ago FRONT PAGE......FAITH AND TIM SPLIT...Of course just like the facebook thing...GARBAGE..So much so that they saying NOTHING.....Thats WHY
OMG..Trying to base a case on circumstantial evidence that is based on WHYS..
TRUST ME FOLKS...WHYS mean NOTHING. Do me a favour....Go pick up some mags today..Ya know the really crappy ones..Read them and then ASK...WHY do none of these stars or PR people who represent them come forward any deny them?? Just a couple of weeks ago FRONT PAGE......FAITH AND TIM SPLIT...Of course just like the facebook thing...GARBAGE..So much so that they saying NOTHING.....Thats WHY
Now you are talking in cirlces and talking aboug stuff irrelevant to the topic. This isn't some big rumor or anything or some big story. It is just the sister of a star with a facebook account, big deal. Stop being so paranoid and making this a bigger deal than it is. Sorry bobby, you are wrong as you have been for so long on many topics. It is true, deal with it.
Hey Ren...I know someone from the STC who has a MUCH stronger opinion of this than you..I was told in no uncertain terms..IT IS A FAKE
Because I have emailed someone close to the STC and they say it is Carrie Ann and they have exchanged posts.
-- Edited by EveryBodyLovesKevy at 11:12, 2009-01-09
REally? Who have you emailed at the STC... There are only 4 staff members and a handful of volunteers... You didn't email me so I know I'm not the one you emailed.
Hey Ren...I know someone from the STC who has a MUCH stronger opinion of this than you..I was told in no uncertain terms..IT IS A FAKE
Because I have emailed someone close to the STC and they say it is Carrie Ann and they have exchanged posts.
-- Edited by EveryBodyLovesKevy at 11:12, 2009-01-09
REally? Who have you emailed at the STC... There are only 4 staff members and a handful of volunteers... You didn't email me so I know I'm not the one you emailed.
Really? YOu claim that this profile is fake but yet band members have contacted her. Is everyone naive but you? I didn't contact you of course but I emailed someone connected to the STC.And I meant to say band members have exchanged posts. And it wouldn't really matter anyway since you are or nobody there is an authority on whose profile is real or fake. Maybe do a little research yourself on Carrie Ann and her profile and who contacted her before claiming it is fake. She won't bite, ask her a question yourself since you claim it is not her. it is no big deal, Shania's sister has a facebook account, lets not get so parnoid.
-- Edited by EveryBodyLovesKevy at 13:14, 2009-01-09
I have a question to ask and maybe someone can help me out here, but Carrie Ann accepted a friend request from me a few days ago, so that I can see her profile and obviously send her messages, but for some reason now, I'm unable to access her wall.
i think its fake,first off she tells everyone the cd is hush hush but talks to random people on the internet about it,she's says that she only uses public photo's what would a fake do.AS far as her profile if we can research it so could a fake,and why would band members contact her on facebook why not just e-mail her?
I have a question to ask and maybe someone can help me out here, but Carrie Ann accepted a friend request from me a few days ago, so that I can see her profile and obviously send her messages, but for some reason now, I'm unable to access her wall.
she is probably doing that now because too many fans are asking her questions. It is her despite what some people here want to believe.
i think its fake,first off she tells everyone the cd is hush hush but talks to random people on the internet about it,she's says that she only uses public photo's what would a fake do.AS far as her profile if we can research it so could a fake,and why would band members contact her on facebook why not just e-mail her?
-- Edited by kelc317 at 14:18, 2009-01-09
You obvioiusly don't have a clue about facebook if you have to ask why not just send email. Instead of saying that it is fake maybe do your own research. Why are you asking people here why the band members contact her through facebook? Go and ask yourself and do your own research.
But she doesn't!!!!!!!!!!! She she won't say anything to just anyone! She has to know you I think. I can't get her to tell me anything.
For the people who think she tells random people stuff about Shania, talk to her & ask her some Shania questions! You'll see she.... I can promise you she won't say anything to you!!!
But she doesn't!!!!!!!!!!! She she won't say anything to just anyone! She has to know you I think. I can't get her to tell me anything.
For the people who think she tells random people stuff about Shania, talk to her & ask her some Shania questions! You'll see she.... I can promise you she won't say anything to you!!!
Don't try and convince these people here of anything. They only believe what they want without doing their own research.Most here thought it was all a lie that Shania would be at the CMA until I was the first to post she was spotted in Nashville. she only told a bit something to peeve and his step dad because they are from timmins and went to her school and she didn't even give details of anything to Peever either. She just said the announcement of when the cd will be out will come very shortly. Big deal, why is everyone so paranoid.
-- Edited by EveryBodyLovesKevy at 14:29, 2009-01-09
-- Edited by EveryBodyLovesKevy at 14:30, 2009-01-09
I have a question to ask and maybe someone can help me out here, but Carrie Ann accepted a friend request from me a few days ago, so that I can see her profile and obviously send her messages, but for some reason now, I'm unable to access her wall.
she is probably doing that now because too many fans are asking her questions. It is her despite what some people here want to believe.
That's a good point. I know it is Carrie, because my contact in Virginia confirmed it was and she wouldn't waste her time writing to her if she thought it was a fake.
I have a question to ask and maybe someone can help me out here, but Carrie Ann accepted a friend request from me a few days ago, so that I can see her profile and obviously send her messages, but for some reason now, I'm unable to access her wall.
she is probably doing that now because too many fans are asking her questions. It is her despite what some people here want to believe.
That's a good point. I know it is Carrie, because my contact in Virginia confirmed it was and she wouldn't waste her time writing to her if she thought it was a fake.
How did she comfirm it ? If you search fake facebook pages you will see there are alot of fake facebook as well as my space pages out there.
kelc317 wrote: How did she comfirm it ? If you search fake facebook pages you will see there are alot of fake facebook as well as my space pages out there.
My contact in Virginia emailed me, she's listed down as 1 of 3 mutual friends on Carrie's profile (along with Grace Billington and Hardy). My contact told me that Shania does not and never will have a MySpace or Facebook profile from the info Carrie passed onto her, and there have been imposters, claiming to be Shania.
This profile is FAKE! I know this for a FACT. I can't say how or why, but, it is NOT Carrie. And I'm friends w/ a couple band members, and they feel it isn't her either but they don't wanna rule it out either. Trust me, I know for a FACT it is NOT Carrie. I just don't want you guys being fooled.
if that profile of carrie is fake, then we really have nothing to say shania is even making new music. maybe she will never be back.
I do believe if Angie says it is fake then it probably is fake. The person must be a real good con person. Shania cannot keep misleading the fans like this. She has given us hints in her letter and her appearance at the CMA that she will be back for sure but I am starting to think the label and Shania are toying with the fans on purpose and lying to them by misleading them. They don't want to say anything because they don't know themself when Shania will get off her butt and into a studio. Maybe she is too busy having love affairs with swiss men. But this misleading of the fans for years has to stop. Shania knows very well about the fans thinking she will have a new album soon but she does nothing to be upfront and clear things up with them. If Shania has no intention of putting out an album this year then the label and her need to tell the fans this and be honest. It is going on 7 years since her last studio album and tons of misleading info by everyone.
i still think that the carrie ann profile is the real deal, and through alot of sources shania is on her way back, any time now. and by the looks of things mutt is involved in the album, have to say so
if that profile of carrie is fake, then we really have nothing to say shania is even making new music. maybe she will never be back.
well we do have her statement at the CMA awards
Shania's statements and words mean nothing anymore.
just like yours
I don't have fans who pay money and support me. I only give my opinion which we are all entitled to. Shania has been cruel to the fans and mislead them for years. She could be upfront with the fans and tell them the truth. Instead she chooses to hide in Europe and never directly tell the fans the truth about music. Shania is too busy having love affairs with weird looking swiss guys, that is her passsion now. So it is time for Shania to tell the fans she is busy with her love life and doesn't want to be bothered by her fans. Let her live in seclusion and retire and give all the money she scammed off the fans back.
i still think that the carrie ann profile is the real deal, and through alot of sources shania is on her way back, any time now. and by the looks of things mutt is involved in the album, have to say so
I hope that you are right and I am trying to look at anything positive now. Angie said the Carrie Ann profile is fake but she didn't say that the news about the album is not true. She would know since she is close to her label and management.
First off kevy Shania didn't scam anything,we bought a product thats it,we didn't buy Shania.Second you should just try a little humility when posting,look at your posts about facebook,some people thought it was fake others thought it was real you just shouldn't be so sure of yourself when dealing with things that are unsure.Now i will say this if Mutt is Shania's producer i will believe your theory that the marriage has been over for a long time or Shania was the one who wanted out.I just can't believe Shania's statement in May and then she is working with him a few months later,then i will believe their is a bunch of stuff we don't know. The only other possibility and its a reach is Shania still loves Mutt and thinks if they work together again she could win him back, i think its a stretch but who knows.
First off kevy Shania didn't scam anything,we bought a product thats it,we didn't buy Shania.Second you should just try a little humility when posting,look at your posts about facebook,some people thought it was fake others thought it was real you just shouldn't be so sure of yourself when dealing with things that are unsure.Now i will say this if Mutt is Shania's producer i will believe your theory that the marriage has been over for a long time or Shania was the one who wanted out.I just can't believe Shania's statement in May and then she is working with him a few months later,then i will believe their is a bunch of stuff we don't know. The only other possibility and its a reach is Shania still loves Mutt and thinks if they work together again she could win him back, i think its a stretch but who knows.
-- Edited by kelc317 at 21:19, 2009-01-09
Kelc317 I couldn't agree with you more! Shania is a person, not a product that has to live her life for other people. We all spent our money on each CD or concert and have gotten a lifetime of music for the investment. To suggest she owes anyone anything beyond the albums she has put out is absolutely ridiculous. I truly hope she comes back a happy and whole person but on her own timetabel
First off kevy Shania didn't scam anything,we bought a product thats it,we didn't buy Shania.Second you should just try a little humility when posting,look at your posts about facebook,some people thought it was fake others thought it was real you just shouldn't be so sure of yourself when dealing with things that are unsure.Now i will say this if Mutt is Shania's producer i will believe your theory that the marriage has been over for a long time or Shania was the one who wanted out.I just can't believe Shania's statement in May and then she is working with him a few months later,then i will believe their is a bunch of stuff we don't know. The only other possibility and its a reach is Shania still loves Mutt and thinks if they work together again she could win him back, i think its a stretch but who knows.
-- Edited by kelc317 at 21:19, 2009-01-09
First off, I am giving Angie the benifit of the doubt, nobody is 100% sure if that is Carrie Ann. Remember Angie also said Frederick and shania are just friends but they are sleeping together and went on a romantic tour. Second off, Shania did mislead and scam the fans. She could of said outright that there would be no cd each of the last many years. But she pretended that one would be out soon. We don't know anything except the fact that Shania could be honest and upfront with the fans but she chooses not to. I call it as I see it. And Shania has totally mislead and scammed the fans. What was her lame ploy of coming to the cma and saying I will be seeing alot of you soon?
First off kevy Shania didn't scam anything,we bought a product thats it,we didn't buy Shania.Second you should just try a little humility when posting,look at your posts about facebook,some people thought it was fake others thought it was real you just shouldn't be so sure of yourself when dealing with things that are unsure.Now i will say this if Mutt is Shania's producer i will believe your theory that the marriage has been over for a long time or Shania was the one who wanted out.I just can't believe Shania's statement in May and then she is working with him a few months later,then i will believe their is a bunch of stuff we don't know. The only other possibility and its a reach is Shania still loves Mutt and thinks if they work together again she could win him back, i think its a stretch but who knows.
-- Edited by kelc317 at 21:19, 2009-01-09
Kelc317 I couldn't agree with you more! Shania is a person, not a product that has to live her life for other people. We all spent our money on each CD or concert and have gotten a lifetime of music for the investment. To suggest she owes anyone anything beyond the albums she has put out is absolutely ridiculous. I truly hope she comes back a happy and whole person but on her own timetabel
Oh really?so she doesn't owe the fans the truth about music. If she wants to sleep around and concentrate on her love life like she is then why not say so. Parading her love life to the public in New York was a direct slap in the face to the fans who thought she is working on music. She has no problem shoving her lover down our faces, why does she have a problem telling the fans about her music plans honestly?
Hey kevy if you believe Shania and Mutt have been having problems for awhile maybe thats the reason there has been no new music,now i believe shania and Fred are more than just friends but again we don't know that they are anything more than just friends,i think time will tell with them
Hey kevy if you believe Shania and Mutt have been having problems for awhile maybe thats the reason there has been no new music,now i believe shania and Fred are more than just friends but again we don't know that they are anything more than just friends,i think time will tell with them
We have been guessing speculating for years about everything. All it would take is for Shania to stop hiding behind people and come out and tell her fans the honest truth. If she says I am lazy and want to concentrate on my love life then we have an answer at least.We won't like it but at least we know the truth. I just care about her music plans. She has played the victim and hid behind everyone while at the same time avoiding questions about music. I think any honest fan can see this. Why shove her lover down our throats in the most public way in New York while at the same time no word about music and no comments to the fans about music. WE have been patient and waiting for years and what does she do? Ingnores answering questions about music but yet has her friends ready to give quotes and make her such a victim in all magazines and she parades Frederick around the world.
But remember Angie also said Shania and frederick are just friends and she said trust her. Friends don't sleep around with eachother. All I am saying is none of us knows for sure. Angie may be right or she may be wrong. I am giving her the benifit of the doubt. but while she is saying the Carrie Ann profile is fake why not stop the rumors and tell us if there will be a Shania album this year or not so none of these false rumors have to continue. Is everyone playing a game with Shania fans and making them believe every year that there is new music only to be told sorry no music again. Why has nobody come out and told the fans the truth?
These are just questions to ponder.
-- Edited by EveryBodyLovesKevy at 23:15, 2009-01-09
This profile is FAKE! I know this for a FACT. I can't say how or why, but, it is NOT Carrie. And I'm friends w/ a couple band members, and they feel it isn't her either but they don't wanna rule it out either. Trust me, I know for a FACT it is NOT Carrie. I just don't want you guys being fooled.
If that is the case, then someone in Shania's circle, should be informed of what's going down. It's not nice for someone pretending to be her sister and leading on the fans, we praise and criticize Shania all we want, but for once, Shania is not at fault here.
Just got an email back from my contact in Virginia.
She already knows about what Angie has been posting, and so does Carrie apparently. And having contacted band members, Hardy said he knew Shania's sister Jill used Facebook and Mark has been on there in the past. She concluded her email by saying that Angie will need more proof and if it's fake, then why hasn't she or the band reported it to Facebook?
First off kevy Shania didn't scam anything,we bought a product thats it,we didn't buy Shania.Second you should just try a little humility when posting,look at your posts about facebook,some people thought it was fake others thought it was real you just shouldn't be so sure of yourself when dealing with things that are unsure.Now i will say this if Mutt is Shania's producer i will believe your theory that the marriage has been over for a long time or Shania was the one who wanted out.I just can't believe Shania's statement in May and then she is working with him a few months later,then i will believe their is a bunch of stuff we don't know. The only other possibility and its a reach is Shania still loves Mutt and thinks if they work together again she could win him back, i think its a stretch but who knows.
-- Edited by kelc317 at 21:19, 2009-01-09
Kelc317 I couldn't agree with you more! Shania is a person, not a product that has to live her life for other people. We all spent our money on each CD or concert and have gotten a lifetime of music for the investment. To suggest she owes anyone anything beyond the albums she has put out is absolutely ridiculous. I truly hope she comes back a happy and whole person but on her own timetabel
Oh really?so she doesn't owe the fans the truth about music. If she wants to sleep around and concentrate on her love life like she is then why not say so. Parading her love life to the public in New York was a direct slap in the face to the fans who thought she is working on music. She has no problem shoving her lover down our faces, why does she have a problem telling the fans about her music plans honestly?
Where do you come up with this stuff? Sleeping around, shoving her lover down our faces?? Who are you to make those kinds of statements. You know nothing about her love life........so she took a trip with a guy.......so what!! Is she never supposed to appear in public? No one knows if she and Fred are an item, or if they are friends who choose not to hide their friendship even though their spouses have made a mess of their two families. You talk about her like she is some object that does not have a right to her own life. Things happen in a person's life that can change the course of it.....that's life. You have set out a path in your head that you think she should follow, and bash her continually because she is not living up to your expectations. You need to get some hobbies other then being a "fan" who continually bashes Shania for being human. Maybe some counselling would be the first place to start. When you decide to bash this post don't worry I won't reply........I've seen your work over and over......you never say anything different and I don't need to defend what I have posted. IT'S EVERYDAY COMMON SENSE!
I don't think anyone begrudges Shania having a personal life. She is a grown adult and is entitled to make her own choices, whether we personally approve of her decisions and actions is not a big deal. But some of us do have a issue with the fact that neither Shania herself or anyone official has not yet informed us- her fans, of her plans career wise. I personally am an active member here at Tommy's because I appreciate Shania as a musical artist. So this is my primary concern. I don't think I am being unreasonable to want to know 1/ Is Shania working on new music 2/ when should we expect the new album 3/are we going to get an announcement any time soon.
I don't think anyone begrudges Shania having a personal life. She is a grown adult and is entitled to make her own choices, whether we personally approve of her decisions and actions is not a big deal. But some of us do have a issue with the fact that neither Shania herself or anyone official has not yet informed us- her fans, of her plans career wise. I personally am an active member here at Tommy's because I appreciate Shania as a musical artist. So this is my primary concern. I don't think I am being unreasonable to want to know 1/ Is Shania working on new music 2/ when should we expect the new album 3/are we going to get an announcement any time soon.
I think your hero does begrudge Shania for having a personal life.The problem with your hero is he attacks Shania for everything.Waiting for new music is fine ,its all the other crap he post's that upset other members.